To celebrate Thanksgiving at a Jersey Shore restaurant, the best choice depends on whether you want a formal sit-down dinner, a family-friendly buffet, or a stress-free feast to take home.
REMEMBER: Thursday, November 26, 2026, is just over a week away, so call immediately to secure reservations or place takeout orders.
Local Spots for Thanksgiving Dinner:
Scarborough Fair Restaurant, Sea Girt
-
- Best For: An upscale, romantic holiday dinner.
- The Experience: Housed in a 19th-century farmhouse just 10 minutes from Wall, this spot is famous for its over-the-top seasonal decor and attentive service. They typically offer a special holiday prix-fixe menu alongside fine dining staples.
- Insider Tip: Book an earlier seating rather than the final slot of the night to ensure the smoothest kitchen pacing and full menu availability. Reservations are required via Scarborough Fair’s website.
Beacon 70, Brick Township, NJ
-
- Best For: A lively, family-friendly buffet with waterfront views.
- The Experience: Located 18 minutes south on the Metedeconk River, Beacon 70 hosts an All-You-Can-Eat Thanksgiving Buffet from 10:00 AM to 6:00 PM. It covers all the traditional holiday classics without any of the cleanup.
- Pricing & Booking: Adults are around $44–$48 and children 12 and under are $24. Reserve online through Beacon 70.
Palmetto Southern Kitchen + Bar, Asbury Park, NJ
-
- Best For: A festive boardwalk buffet with Southern comfort flair.
- The Experience: About 22 minutes north in Asbury Park, Palmetto puts a flavorful Lowcountry spin on its Thanksgiving Buffet, pairing classic carved turkey with standout sides and signature cornbread.
- Insider Tip: Request a table near the boardwalk windows for ocean views, and allow extra time for paid street or lot parking. Book through Palmetto Southern Kitchen.
The Cabin Restaurant, Freehold, NJ
- Best For: Large, casual groups seeking a hearty carving-station spread.
- The Experience: A 16-minute drive west, this rustic log cabin tavern serves a dedicated Thanksgiving Day Buffet featuring roast turkey and prime rib carving stations, house stuffing, and signature soups
- Insider Tip: The atmosphere is warm and high-energy rather than quiet; call ahead directly to confirm seating times for larger parties. Check details on The Cabin’s website.
Very Nice Sit-Down Restaurants:
Amelia’s By the Sea, Spring Lake, NJ
-
- Best For: A relaxed, upscale oceanfront sit-down meal with table service.
- The Experience: Located just 7 to 10 minutes away on Ocean Avenue in Spring Lake, Amelia’s offers a cozy, white-tablecloth dining room with Atlantic views. Unlike the buffet spots on the list, they serve a traditional Thanksgiving Day menu from 11:30 AM to 8:00 PM featuring holiday specials alongside à la carte modern Italian and seafood favorites.
- Booking Details: Reservations are required and fill up fast for ocean-view tables; book directly through Amelia’s By the Sea or call (732) 769-5700.
Spring Lake Manor, Spring Lake, NJ
-
- Best For: A classic, grand banquet-style Thanksgiving buffet right in the neighborhood.
- The Experience: Situated right on Route 71 in Spring Lake (under 10 minutes from Wall), this historic venue hosts an annual Thanksgiving Day Dinner Buffet starting at 2:00 PM with 90-minute seatings. Expect carved turkey, prime rib, seafood, and extensive dessert tables in a chandelier-lit dining room.
- Booking Details: Pricing is typically around $60 per adult, and reservations can only be made by calling Spring Lake Manor directly at (732) 449-6630.
Other Notable Dining Alternatives
- For historic charm and a quiet dining room: Our House Restaurant in Farmingdale serves a popular, family-run Thanksgiving buffet inside a restored 1747 building.
- For a grand hotel brunch-to-dinner feast: The Dining Room at the Molly Pitcher Inn in Red Bank offers an upscale carving-station buffet overlooking the Navesink River.
- For a boardwalk buffet: McLoone’s Pier House in Long Branch features ocean views with turkey and roast beef carving stations.


